On August 16, Phoenix Planning and Development Director Josh Bednarik spent nearly two hours answering residents' questions about the data center going up at 48th Street and Thistle Landing Drive. Most of his answers came back to one decision made about three decades ago. Ahwatukee Foothills News reported that he told the meeting, sponsored by the Ahwatukee Community Alliance, that the property was rezoned to Commerce Park/General Commerce Park in 1996.
"The vote that the council took to approve the rezoning of that site in 1996 is really what positioned this site for this kind of investment."
For anyone comparing Ahwatukee Foothills with other parts of the Valley, the useful lesson goes beyond one campus. A nearby parcel's zoning decides what it can become, whatever stands on it today. A rule adopted later usually can't undo rights that were set earlier. The Thistle Landing site shows how both of those things work.
A call center site with data-center rights
California-based Menlo Equities bought the 40.6-acre site in 2015 for $50.2 million. At the time it held a four-building call center, which the company has since demolished. In its place, Menlo Digital is building a five-building office and data center campus of about 1 million square feet.
A neighbor looking at that property ten years ago saw offices and a parking lot. The zoning already allowed far more. When the parcel was rezoned in the 1990s, Phoenix's code had no definition for a modern data center. According to Bednarik, the city classified such facilities under existing categories, such as a "telecom hotel" or an office use. The city's own staff report says Phoenix had been handling data centers through informal interpretation because they were neither defined nor listed as a use.
That's why the project needed no rezoning and no council hearing on its use. Menlo's site plan was approved in 2024. When residents asked why the city keeps processing permits, Bednarik said the project was in building-plan review and no council vote was pending.
The Ahwatukee Community Alliance, chaired by Craig Evans, disputes the city's reading. In a later Ahwatukee Foothills News report, Evans argued that commerce park zoning allows some light industry only if it stays inside the building. He pointed to the campus's rooftop cooling fans and its 120 diesel-powered emergency generators.
The project's name added to the confusion. Opponents say residents were asked to support what was presented as the "Thistle Technology Center." Bednarik answered that the label may matter little under the zoning code if both uses were permitted on the property.
Why the 2025 rules stop short of Thistle Landing
Phoenix did write data-center rules. The City Council adopted text amendment Z-TA-2-25-Y as Ordinance G-7396, with final action on July 2, 2025. The city's May 2025 staff report proposed the following:
- A definition for data centers, plus a Special Permit requirement in the C-2, C-3, CP/GCP, A-1 and A-2 districts
- A minimum 150-foot setback for mechanical equipment from abutting rights-of-way or residentially zoned property, along with screening
- A noise study and mitigation for sites within 300 feet of residential zoning
- A utility "will-serve" letter and 2,640 feet of separation from approved high-capacity transit
The ordinance text in the council's July 2, 2025 formal agenda makes the noise rule concrete. A data center can't receive preliminary site plan approval unless it's shown that the facility and its on-site mechanical equipment won't exceed the site's existing ambient noise level by more than 5%, or a specific noise standard is set as a condition of a special permit.
Those rules arrived after Menlo's 2024 site plan, and the city says they don't cover it. Bednarik linked that to Proposition 207, the Private Property Rights Protection Act that Arizona voters approved in 2006. He said it limits the city's ability to impose new land-use rules on property after development rights are established without risking a claim for compensation. Menlo signed a Proposition 207 waiver when it modified its site plan in 2024. Bednarik said that waiver applied to the site-plan change and not to the underlying zoning.
"We can't just take that rule book and now apply a 2025 rule to something that got approval in 2024."
Councilman Kevin Robinson, whose District 6 includes Ahwatukee, said the 2025 regulations sharply restrict where future facilities can be built but can't erase existing property rights.
| Date | What happened at 48th Street and Thistle Landing |
|---|---|
| 1996 | Site rezoned to Commerce Park/General Commerce Park, according to Bednarik |
| 2006 | Arizona voters approve Proposition 207 |
| 2015 | Menlo Equities buys the 40.6-acre call center site |
| 2024 | Menlo's site plan approved |
| July 2, 2025 | Phoenix adopts its data-center ordinance, G-7396 |
| Aug. 16, 2026 | Alliance meeting with Robinson and Bednarik |
| Oct. 16, 2026 | Outdoor construction returns to winter hours |
Each later rule arrived after the rights it might have limited had already been set.
The water figure and the noise question
Menlo estimates the whole development will use about 8.1 million gallons of water a year. It says roughly 90% of that goes to landscaping and about 826,725 gallons to the five buildings themselves. Menlo compares that with an estimated 23.7 million gallons a year for a single-family development on the same land and 33.1 million gallons for multifamily housing. Those numbers come from the company and haven't been independently measured. Because Phoenix is the site's water provider, its Water Services Department can monitor actual consumption.
The low water use comes from the cooling design. Menlo says it will use closed-loop, air-cooled chillers in place of evaporative cooling, and air cooling takes thousands of fans and other mechanical equipment running around the clock. So the system that saves water is also the source of the noise questions.
Bednarik described 55 decibels as the city's general noise standard. Menlo cites its own 2024 measurements of about 55 decibels during the day and 45 at night in the surrounding neighborhood. Bednarik also pointed out that sound is barely reviewed before a project starts operating, because it isn't covered by the building code or the zoning ordinance. He said his department is looking into whether Phoenix can require noise testing before it issues a certificate of occupancy. Menlo says it has hired acoustical expertise, runs two noise-monitoring stations around the clock during construction, and has designed the backup generators with sound attenuation, exhaust silencers and vibration isolation.
Where oversight stands this fall
With the city treating the use as allowed, the oversight still underway is mostly operational. After neighbors complained, Phoenix began stationing inspectors on site early each workday. The contractor agreed to move construction traffic farther from homes, limit early deliveries, relocate employee parking and monitor noise, according to Ahwatukee Foothills News. Since October 16, outdoor work has been limited to 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on weekdays unless the city issues a special permit, and Planning Director Joshua Bednarik told residents his department won't issue one for this campus.
The 120 generators also go through a separate review by the Maricopa County Air Quality Department. The county required Menlo to resubmit air-permit applications covering all five buildings, and a hearing was planned for November. Evans has said that process covers "air quality and air quality alone." The county posts its notices on its Public Notices page. Separately, Attorney General Kris Mayes said at an October 14 town hall that her office has an open nuisance investigation into the facility. Ahwatukee Foothills News reported that this inquiry is separate from any review of the city's approval.
What this changes about due diligence in Ahwatukee
Most buyers judge a nearby nonresidential parcel by what it looks like today, whether that's an office park, a call center or an empty lot. Thistle Landing shows that the zoning matters more. In practical terms:
- Look up the zoning on nearby nonresidential parcels. A commerce park designation from decades ago can allow uses no one had in mind when the vote was taken.
- Ask when the rights were set. At Thistle Landing, the city pointed to a 2024 site-plan approval and Proposition 207 to explain why its 2025 rules don't apply. How that works for any other parcel is a question for a land-use attorney.
- Use the purpose-built rules as a reference point. The 2025 ordinance shows what Phoenix now requires of new data-center sites. A site approved earlier may not have to meet it.
- Follow more than one agency. Construction hours, air permits and certificates of occupancy are handled by different offices on different schedules.
This is general information about how these rules have been applied at one site, and it is not legal advice. Before you rely on any zoning or property-rights question for a specific property, confirm it with a land-use attorney or the City of Phoenix Planning and Development Department.
Quick answers
Did the City Council vote on the data center? Not on its use. Bednarik said no council vote was pending. He described a July council vote abandoning a drainage easement as procedural.
How often will the generators run? Menlo says they provide backup power during outages and otherwise run for periodic testing and maintenance. Robinson said the company told him testing would normally happen once a month for about 15 minutes.
How much parking will the campus have? The plans call for 207 spaces, along with landscaping, architectural screening and a public park.
If you're considering a home in the Ahwatukee Foothills and want to know what the parcels around it are already zoned to allow, Arizona Proper Real Estate can pull that history before you write an offer. Schedule a private consultation, and our buyer's guide covers the rest of the process.